Monday, December 1, 2008

The Great Cookie Debate


Hello my name is Sahu and I am an addict. My addiction is chocolate chip cookies. I probably eaten more chocolate chip cookies in a week than most people have in a lifetime. It kind of freaks me out if I think about it for too long, then I usually shove a cookie in my face and all the bad thoughts go away.

Most people know this about me and consequently recommend that I try different cookies because they think that was the best cookie they ever had. I am not saying I am the arbiter of all chocolate chip cookie taste but people always insist I try their recommendations and are generally disappointed when I give them my review because I usually don't pull any punches.

Below is a run down of the places and brands I have tried and my thoughts (in no particular order):
  • Wholefoods Market chocolate chip cookies - Right now these are my gold standard. They are baked fresh everyday and the freshest will have a sell by date 4 days out. I don't even remember how I came across them but it was about 3-4 years ago and I haven't gone a week without at least one tub (usually 3 or 4)
  • City Bakery - These cookies were recommended my poker playing friend Carl (who you can find here and here and here). He has recommended several places and these are the best of his recommendation. Overall the cookies was OK they are pretty big and baked fresh everyday. Unfortunately, it seems like they are baked at the same time or in the same oven with a bunch of other types of cookies and so the chocolate chip cookies end up tasting like some of the other cookies.
  • Levine Bakery - This was another recommendation from Carl. It is a tiny place on the upper west side and their cookies are over the top huge. I feel like it is a cookie I would get if I were in Minnesota. Also they don't have a pure chocolate chip cookies their have a chocolate chip cookie with walnuts and a double chocolate chip cookie.
  • Insomnia Cookies - This is another small place located on 8th street between 5th and 6th ave. The cookies here were not very memorable. I only remember when I was eating them how bland they were. I am not sure if it was because of the chocolate chip or the cookie.
  • The Grand Lux Cafe @ The Venetian casino in Las Vegas - These cookies were discovered and sufficiently hyped up by Jeff and Jenny while they were on their wedding/WSOP trip. These cookies very nearly lived up to their hype. They were freshly baked and you had to order them when you first sit as they take 30 min to bake. Generally, I hate any type of nuts in my cookies and these cookies had pecans but they were not overbearing and for the most part not even noticeable.
Desperate times call for desperate measures:
  • Entenmann's Cookies - These are an old stand by when I don't have wholefoods accessible to me and I am in desperate need for a cookie these are perfectly serviceable. 
  • Pepperidge Farms - They have several chocolate chip cookies and the best ones are the soft baked dark chocolate chip. But I generally stick to the double chocolate milano where pepperidge farms is concerned.
  • Chips Ahoy! - When I was young and ignorant I crushed these cookies like there was nothing better in the world and now these are barely serviceable only if there is absolutely no way of getting any other cookie and you are starting to get the shakes.
I will update this post as I try different cookies and as I get other recommendations but if you ever tell me to try this I will have to give you a stern back handed bitch slap.

1 comment:

Buddha said...

My dear Cookie Monster. I appreciate the mention of my cookie favorites even if you do not give them the credit that they are due. Your anti-nut bias must go so that you might truly appreciate Levain and I have no clue what you're talking about re the City Bakery contaminated flavor cookies, I think we been smoking a little something there.

I am also troubled that you go for the Pepperidge Farm soft-baked cookies. The only soft cookies are cookies fresh from the oven. Cookies in a bag that are soft are unnatural, kept soft by evil chemicals produced by Big Pharma. If you're going to go Pepperidge, go dark chocolate chip HARD cookies, never soft. Even better, go with crispy thin Tates Chocolate Chip cookies Double chocolate Milano is fine, although I prefer the singles. And yes, Entenmann's can fulfill a fix, if one must. Even though they are evilly soft.

Capeche?

Share This

Bookmark and Share